The Masked Singer’s Paparazzo Revealed as This ’90s Teen Heartthrob

This boy has met a whole new side of himself on The Masked Singer.

A former ’90s teen heartthrob was eliminated during the Fox singing competition series’ April 16 episode—but not before proving to himself and viewers that he has quite the impressive vocal chops.

“If you had told me that this little guy would still be standing here, I’d say, ‘You’re crazy,’ because I’ve never sang before,” the TV and film star—disguised as season 13 character Paparazzo—admitted during a video package. “And—big spoiler alert—this next song is the biggest hint to my identity yet.”

But before revealing his song, Paparazzo dropped a major hint about his true identity in the form of an appearance from Boy Meets World alum Danielle Fishel (a.k.a. Topanga from the beloved ’90s sitcom).

The mystery celebrity then hit the stage and belted out a cover of TLC‘s hit “Unpretty.”

Afterwards, the judges got 30 seconds to ask Paparazzo a series of questions, the most telling of which was if he’d ever been on a hit TV show. His answer? “Oh yeah!”