The White Lotus’ Haley Lu Richardson “Stalked” Aubrey Plaza

This isn’t the first time the stars have discussed Richardson’s obsession. In a Nov. 4 conversation between the two published by Interview Magazine, Plaza admitted that Richardson “stalked me for years” and got her a necklace “that says ‘mommy’ on it,” while Richardson herself revealed that she has an “Aubrey” album on her phone that’s “all about important moments for us.” Very Ingrid Goes West of her.

And, of course, Plaza didn’t forget the infamous birthday party incident. either. 

“It didn’t matter how many mushrooms I had taken that night,” she explained. “I knew that my stalker had arrived. But there was something deep down inside all along that was like, ‘Even though she’s stalking me, and maybe eventually she’ll cut me up into a million pieces and eat me, I like her. In fact, I love her.’ And so when I heard that you were cast on The White Lotus, I was like, ‘This is some f–king witchy karmic shit.'”

The White Lotus airs Sundays at 9 p.m. ET on HBO and HBO Max.